- AI Platforms & Assistants
- Gemini
It's a trade between privacy and convenience
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
(Image credit: Google)
- Copy link
- X
- Threads
I think we all know that the messages we type into AI chatbots aren't entirely private. They can be used to train future AI models, for example, and most AI companies have some version of human review in their training and quality-improvement processes. But when I loaded up Gemini today, it hit me with a warning message that felt more urgent:
"Humans review some saved chats to improve Google AI. To stop this for future chats, turn off Gemini Apps activity. If this setting is on, don't enter info that you wouldn't want reviewed or used."
By issuing the warning message, Google is being unusually explicit here. It's making it clear that this is different from simply storing your chat history. It's specifically about using conversations for product improvement and quality control.
Latest Videos FromWatch full video here: You may like
-
I tried importing my ChatGPT memory into Gemini
-
Gemini's new AI meter has changed the way I use the chatbot
-
I made ChatGPT act like Gemini
I'm not entirely sure why Gemini decided to show me this warning today — I'd not changed anything about my Pro subscription recently — but other users have noticed the same message appearing over the last couple of months.
Anyway, I decided to turn it off, since nobody wants other people reviewing their chats, and that's when I discovered the hidden cost that Gemini asks users to accept.
The privacy tradeoff I wasn't expecting
I clicked through to Gemini Apps Activity to turn the feature off. First, a bit of explanation about why the setting is called "Gemini Apps Activity", because it has very little to do with what most of us would think of as apps.
"Gemini Apps Activity" is really a legacy Google naming convention. It essentially means your interactions with Gemini and connected Google services. Because Gemini can reach into Gmail, Calendar, Drive, and other Google products, Google treats it as part of a broader activity ecosystem rather than simply a chatbot chat log.
Get daily insight, inspiration and deals in your inboxContact me with news and offers from other Future brandsReceive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsorsBy submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.Confusing naming convention aside, let's look at what turning the setting off actually does. Here's the kicker: if you disable Gemini Apps Activity, Google will only let you continue conversations if you respond within a 72-hour window. After that, they disappear.
So, imagine you start a conversation with Gemini on Friday evening. Maybe you're planning a vacation, researching a health concern, or working through a complicated career decision. If you don't return to that chat within 72 hours, Gemini won't keep it around. This means that the privacy-friendly option comes with a surprising consequence: your AI assistant stops being able to remember long-running conversations unless you are frequently updating them.
For quick questions, that limitation may not matter. But for the kind of ongoing conversations AI companies like to encourage — planning projects, exploring ideas, or seeking advice over time — it feels like a significant compromise.
What to read next-
What people confessed to me about using ChatGPT surprised me
-
Gemini leads in human-like AI writing as detection tools fall behind
-
Google expands Gemini into an AI agent
ChatGPT does it differently
I don't want to accept that limitation to my Gemini chats, so right now I'm stuck with allowing Google staff to review my chats and use them as training data.
ChatGPT and Gemini both offer ways to limit how your conversations are used, but they frame the choice differently. In ChatGPT, I can switch off Improve the model for everyone and continue using the service much as before. In Gemini, the decision is wrapped up in the broader Gemini Apps Activity setting, where turning it off also means giving up long-term chat history.
At a time when AI companies are pushing users to treat chatbots as personal assistants, therapists, life coaches, and memory systems, Gemini is simultaneously reminding users that some conversations may be reviewed by humans while making it harder to maintain long-term conversations if you opt out.
In ChatGPT, if you select Settings, go to Data Controls, and turn off Improve the model for everyone, you're good to go without any impact on your saved conversations.
With ChatGPT, opting out feels like changing a privacy setting. With Gemini, it feels like making a tradeoff that users shouldn't have to make.
Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds.
The best laptops for all budgetsOur top picks, based on real-world testing and comparisons➡️ Read our full guide to the best laptops1. Best overall: Apple MacBook Air 13-inch M52. Best budget: Apple MacBook Neo3. Best Windows 11 laptopMicrosoft Surface Laptop 13-inch4. Best thin and light:Lenovo Yoga Slim 9i5. Best UltrabookAsus Zenbook S 16
TOPICS AI Google
Graham BarlowSocial Links NavigationSenior Editor, AIGraham is the Senior Editor for AI at TechRadar. With over 25 years of experience in both online and print journalism, Graham has worked for various market-leading tech brands including Computeractive, PC Pro, iMore, MacFormat, Mac|Life, Maximum PC, and more. He specializes in reporting on everything to do with AI and has appeared on BBC TV shows like BBC One Breakfast and on Radio 4 commenting on the latest trends in tech. Graham has an honors degree in Computer Science and spends his spare time podcasting and blogging.
View MoreYou must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
Logout Read more
Gemini
I tried importing my ChatGPT memory into Gemini
Gemini
Gemini's new AI meter has changed the way I use the chatbot
ChatGPT
I made ChatGPT act like Gemini
AI Platforms & Assistants
What people confessed to me about using ChatGPT surprised me
AI Platforms & Assistants
Gemini leads in human-like AI writing as detection tools fall behind
Gemini
Gemini used my Google Photos library to get personal when making images
Latest in Gemini
Phones
Leica says generative AI ‘makes perfect sense’ for smartphones, but admits it's unlikely to come to Leica M cameras
Search Engines
Researchers say Google AI Mode changes recommendations based on your emails
Gemini
Gemini's new AI meter has changed the way I use the chatbot
Televisions
Google TV could get Wii-style pointy controls, like LG's divisive Magic Remote
Gemini
5 prompts for Gemini 3.5 Flash showcasing its full potential
AI Platforms & Assistants
Gemini Omni pushes AI creativity
Latest in Opinion
CPU
Intel says it 'welcomes the competition' from Nvidia's new RTX Spark CPU
Pro
AR glasses are here – and displays are defining their future
Pro
The cyber risk framework protecting your organization wasn't built for this adversary
Pro
Solving the enterprise data optimization problem
Pro
The hidden enterprise security risk of consumer-grade tools
Pro
The AI availability gap is real, and it has nothing to do with the model
LATEST ARTICLES- 1‘We need an AI that places humanity first’: Microsoft AI CEO outlines hopes to build “humanist superintelligence” - and has seven new models to help him do it
- 2Rivian boss says Level 4 autonomous driving is "much closer than people think", but Tesla is struggling to convince its own employees that the technology is reliable
- 3'Stop duct-taping human email into machine workflows' — Hostinger unleashes Agentic Mail to fix the biggest bottleneck in AI automation
- 4'A new approach': Microsoft CEO claims its "AI Superfactory" will use the same amount of water each year as a neighborhood restaurant
- 5Quordle hints and answers for Wednesday, June 3 (game #1591)